Sources & Standards
Evidence Grades
Two different judgments
REALPROJECTAMERICA keeps two questions separate:
- How well can this source prove this particular fact? That receives a source grade.
- How strongly does all the evidence support our conclusion? That receives a confidence rating.
An authentic speech can prove exactly what a politician said. It does not, by itself, prove that everything said in the speech is true.
Source grades
We use the familiar school-style grades A, B, C, D, and F. There is no E and no plus or minus grade.
| Grade | What it means | What it can establish |
|---|---|---|
| A — Authoritative record | Enacted laws, official vote records, court opinions and dockets, executive orders, regulations, official filings, certified election results, and original government datasets. | Can establish what the responsible institution officially recorded, did, or decided. Does not automatically prove unrelated assertions contained in the record. |
| B — Direct primary evidence | A complete speech, transcript, interview, original video or audio, campaign platform, first-party statement, or authenticated document. | Can establish what a person or organization said, showed, promised, or published. Separate evidence may be needed to prove the underlying factual claim. |
| C — Strong independent reporting or analysis | Reputable reporting based on named sources and documents, peer-reviewed research, and transparent nonpartisan analysis. | Useful for context and supported conclusions. When an original record is available, we try to link to it directly. |
| D — Limited or interested source | Partisan or advocacy analysis, opinion, an incomplete excerpt, or a report whose underlying support is not available. | May identify a useful lead or viewpoint, but normally needs stronger independent support before we rely on it. |
| F — Fails verification | Rumors, anonymous social-media posts, unattributed screenshots, fabricated material, decontextualized clips, unsourced summaries, and AI-generated answers. | Never treated as evidence for the underlying claim. May be kept as a research lead or used to document that misinformation circulated. |
A grade is not permanent
We grade a source for the specific fact it is being used to support. We do not permanently assign one grade to an entire newspaper, government agency, political party, advocacy group, or person.
Conclusion confidence
- Confirmed: Conclusive authoritative evidence, or multiple independent high-quality sources, directly establishes the narrowly worded conclusion.
- Strongly supported: Reliable evidence supports the conclusion, but a limited gap or reasonable qualification remains.
- Mixed or contested: Reliable evidence conflicts or supports different parts of the conclusion.
- Inconclusive: There is not enough evidence to choose among plausible conclusions.
- Unverified: The assertion has not been adequately authenticated or corroborated. It may be described as someone's claim, but not stated as fact.
We reconsider confidence when material new evidence appears.